The call, on record
TSLA bearish call
Target Price
$17
Quoted text as recorded“Tesla you know you know last day look BMW was it was 60 billion euros or something it's got 3.2 billion shares outstanding so you're looking at I don't know 17 a share are you [ __ ] [ __ ] maybe I mean that's what that's what the damn thing is generously worth”@ 4:10 · open at this moment on YouTube ↗
Our interpretation
- Source published
- Mar 6, 2023
- Interpreted confidence
- high
- Specificity
- specific
Why this call is unscored
- Status
- expired
- Notes
- No stated deadline is recorded. Archived after 12 months without a scored outcome; this is not a missed deadline.
Email me when TSLA calls resolve
When a tracked TSLA call is scored — hit, miss or partial — we’ll email you the result. No account needed.
Used only for these updates. Privacy
Evidence and source
Our summary of the thesis
Strongly BearishStructured interpretation of the video, not a verbatim quotation. Check the source for conditions, emphasis and context.
Mark Spiegel views Tesla as absurdly overvalued at 70 times earnings, arguing the company is losing its technological edge to competitors with better charging speeds and interiors. He believes Tesla's recent massive price cuts will significantly reduce profit margins and that the company faces increasing competition from Chinese automakers and traditional manufacturers like GM.
Key arguments
- Tesla trading at 70 times earnings is fundamentally overvalued
- Company has slashed prices massively, reducing profit per car by approximately half
- Tesla now has trailing edge technology compared to competitors with faster charging and nicer interiors
- Full self-driving program contains blatant fraud with fake promotional videos
- Chinese competitors like BYD and traditional automakers like GM are releasing superior electric vehicles
- Tesla is losing market share and will face earnings contraction due to price cuts
Counter-arguments acknowledged
- Acknowledges Tesla had a great head start in the EV market
- Recognizes Tesla as the most popular retail stock worldwide
Hedges and caveats (from the video)
- Spiegel acknowledges he is 'making up numbers' when discussing Tesla's beta relative to NASDAQ
- The video is a critical review/interview format rather than direct investment advice from the channel
- Spiegel's 10-year short position on Tesla has resulted in significant losses ('super ouch')
- Spiegel makes subjective claims about 'blatant fraud' without detailed substantiation in the excerpt
- The analysis relies heavily on opinion ('trust me I'm an expert') rather than rigorous financial modeling
About this record
Reviewed by a moderatorAI-extracted record. A quote, summary and outcome each need their own context. Moderator review does not certify investment performance.
- Source published
- Mar 6, 2023, 1:51 AM UTC
- First recorded by TubeRank
- Apr 20, 2026, 9:09 AM UTC
- Record last updated
- Oct 6, 2026, 6:32 AM UTC
- Moderator review recorded
- Not recorded
- Transcript provenance
- YouTube captions (manual or automatic)
- Recorded analysis processor/source label
- claude-sonnet-4-20250514
- This can identify a workflow rather than an exact AI model version.
- Extraction pipeline version
- v1.0.0
- Outcome methodology version
- 2026-10-06.5
- Outcome reason code
- expired_without_stated_deadline
Recent record changes 4 shown
Oct 6, 2026, 6:32 AM UTC
corrected
- Outcome methodology version
Before2026-10-06.4
After2026-10-06.5
Oct 6, 2026, 5:14 AM UTC
corrected
- Outcome methodology version
Before2026-10-06.2
After2026-10-06.4
Oct 6, 2026, 4:00 AM UTC
corrected
- Outcome methodology version
Before2026-10-06.1
After2026-10-06.2
Oct 6, 2026, 3:27 AM UTC
expired without stated deadline
- Outcome methodology version
BeforeNot recorded
After2026-10-06.1
- Direction-adjusted price movement (%)
Before-106.71
AfterNot recorded
- Reference price
Before193.81
AfterNot recorded
- Recorded outcome date
Before2026-04-20
After2026-10-06
- Outcome explanation
BeforeMissing deadline. Prediction over 12 months old. Price: $400.62.
AfterNo stated deadline is recorded. Archived after 12 months without a scored outcome; this is not a missed deadline.
- Outcome price
Before400.62
AfterNot recorded
- Outcome reason
BeforeNot recorded
AfterExpired without stated deadline
Showing up to 20 recent changes. The complete feed has 5 recorded events for this call, including its initial entry. Read the full paginated history (JSON); follow nextCursor while hasMore is true.
Stored outcome evidence
- Stored reference price
- Not recorded
- Not recorded · provider not recorded
- Target as extracted
- $17
- Stated deadline as extracted
- None recorded
- Recorded outcome date
- Oct 6, 2026
- Outcome price observation
- Not recorded
- Not recorded · provider not recorded
Stored explanation
No stated deadline is recorded. Archived after 12 months without a scored outcome; this is not a missed deadline.
Missing timestamps, providers and versions are historical gaps. Stored observations can include daily closes; they do not show every intraday touch or prove an executable trade. Read the methodology.
Why we interpreted the confidence this way
Uses strong certainty language 'that's what the damn thing is generously worth' and has maintained short position for 10 years despite losses